
Peer Review Process
Journal of Societal Innovation (JSI) applies a rigorous double-blind peer-review process to ensure the quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly integrity of all manuscripts considered for publication. Under double-blind review, the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process.
All manuscripts submitted to JSI are evaluated solely on the basis of their academic merit, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, methodological and analytical quality, originality, and contribution to the understanding of societal innovation.
1. Initial Editorial Screening
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial screening by the editorial team before being sent for external peer review.
The editorial screening assesses:
- relevance to the aims and scope of JSI;
- originality and scholarly contribution;
- compliance with the journal's author guidelines;
- quality and clarity of academic writing;
- adequacy of the theoretical or conceptual foundation;
- appropriateness of the research design and methodology;
- completeness of ethical information, where applicable; and
- compliance with publication ethics and research integrity standards.
Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope, lack sufficient scholarly quality, fail to comply substantially with the author guidelines, or raise serious ethical concerns may be rejected at this stage without external peer review.
2. Similarity and Research Integrity Screening
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening may undergo similarity checking using appropriate similarity-detection software.
Similarity scores are not used as the sole basis for editorial decisions. The editorial team evaluates the nature, context, and extent of textual similarity.
Where substantial overlap, plagiarism, duplicate publication, inappropriate citation practices, data fabrication, falsification, or other potential research-integrity concerns are identified, the editorial team may request clarification, require revision, reject the manuscript, or take further action in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics Policy.
3. Selection and Assignment of Reviewers
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are normally assigned to at least two independent reviewers who have appropriate expertise in the subject area of the manuscript.
Reviewers are selected on the basis of:
- subject-matter expertise;
- relevant academic qualifications;
- research and publication experience;
- independence from the authors and the submitted research;
- absence of significant conflicts of interest; and
- ability to provide a constructive and scholarly evaluation within the requested timeframe.
Whenever possible, reviewers are selected from institutions different from those of the authors.
The final selection of reviewers is made by the Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor.
4. Double-Blind Peer Review
JSI uses a double-blind peer-review system. Authors must ensure that identifying information is removed from the manuscript submitted for review.
Reviewers are not informed of the authors' identities, and authors are not informed of the reviewers' identities.
The editorial team makes reasonable efforts to preserve anonymity throughout the review process. However, complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed where authors reveal their identities indirectly through self-citations, research settings, publicly available datasets, preprints, or other contextual information.
5. Criteria for Peer Review
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts critically, objectively, and constructively. The evaluation should consider the following aspects:
Originality and significance The manuscript should present an original contribution or provide a meaningful extension, reinterpretation, or synthesis of existing knowledge.
Relevance to societal innovation The manuscript should demonstrate a clear relationship to innovation, societal change, societal transformation, or societal impact.
Theoretical or conceptual contribution The manuscript should be grounded in relevant theories, concepts, or scholarly debates and clearly explain its contribution to existing knowledge.
Research design and methodology The research questions, methods, data sources, sampling strategies, analytical procedures, and other methodological decisions should be appropriate, transparent, and sufficiently rigorous.
Analysis and interpretation The findings should be supported by the evidence presented, and interpretations should be logically developed and appropriately connected to relevant literature.
Ethical integrity Manuscripts reporting research that involves human participants, communities, or sensitive data should provide appropriate information on ethical approval, informed consent, confidentiality, and other relevant safeguards.
Quality of discussion and conclusions The discussion should clearly explain the significance of the findings and their relationship to existing scholarship. Conclusions should be supported by the findings and should not overstate the evidence.
Scholarly contribution The manuscript should demonstrate a meaningful theoretical, methodological, empirical, policy, professional, or societal contribution.
Quality of presentation The manuscript should be logically organised, clearly written, appropriately referenced, and presented according to the journal's academic and editorial standards.
6. Reviewer Recommendations
After completing their assessment, reviewers may recommend one of the following editorial outcomes:
Accept The manuscript is suitable for publication with no substantial revisions.
Minor Revision The manuscript requires limited revisions that do not substantially alter its central arguments, methodology, or findings.
Major Revision The manuscript requires substantial changes to its theoretical framework, methodology, analysis, interpretation, discussion, presentation, or other significant components.
Reject The manuscript does not meet the journal's scholarly standards, contains fundamental problems that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision, or falls outside the journal's scope.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor, who considers the reviewers' reports, the manuscript's scholarly contribution, ethical considerations, and the quality of the authors' responses to revision requests.
7. Author Revision
Authors invited to revise their manuscript must submit a revised manuscript and a detailed response to reviewers explaining how each comment has been addressed.
The response should identify the revisions made and, where a recommendation has not been followed, provide a clear academic justification.
Authors should respond respectfully and substantively to all reviewer and editor comments.
8. Further Review
Manuscripts requiring major revision may be returned to the original reviewers for reassessment.
Additional rounds of peer review may be conducted when necessary, particularly where substantial methodological, theoretical, analytical, or ethical concerns remain unresolved.
The editorial team may also invite an additional reviewer when:
- reviewer reports substantially disagree;
- specialised expertise is required;
- a potential conflict of interest emerges; or
- further independent assessment is necessary to support a fair editorial decision.
9. Final Editorial Decision
Following peer review and any required revisions, the editor evaluates the complete review record and makes the final editorial decision.
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit and are not influenced by the authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, ethnicity, religion, political views, professional status, or other characteristics unrelated to academic quality.
Acceptance for publication is not determined solely by reviewer voting or numerical recommendations. Editors retain responsibility for ensuring that published articles meet the academic, ethical, and editorial standards of JSI.
10. Production and Publication
Once a manuscript has been formally accepted, it proceeds to the production stage, which may include copyediting, language and technical editing, reference verification, metadata checking, layout preparation, proofreading, DOI registration, and final publication.
Authors may be asked to review the final proof before publication. Proof corrections should normally be limited to typographical, formatting, factual, or production-related errors. Substantial changes to the accepted manuscript require editorial approval.
Review Timeline
JSI seeks to provide authors with a careful and efficient review process.
The initial editorial screening is normally completed within 7–10 days after submission.
Reviewers are generally requested to submit their reports within 3–4 weeks after accepting a review invitation.
Authors are normally given between 7 and 21 days to complete revisions, depending on whether minor or major revisions are required.
These timeframes are indicative rather than guaranteed. The duration of the review process may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the number of revision rounds required, and other scholarly or ethical considerations.
JSI prioritises the quality and integrity of peer review over unusually rapid publication decisions.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scholarly quality and integrity of JSI.
Reviewers are expected to provide an objective, constructive, evidence-based, and respectful assessment of the manuscript. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate.
Reviewer comments should clearly distinguish between major concerns affecting the validity or contribution of the manuscript and minor recommendations intended to improve clarity or presentation.
Reviewers should identify relevant published work that has not been appropriately acknowledged where such information is important to the evaluation of the manuscript.
Reviewers must not require authors to cite the reviewer's own publications unless those references are genuinely relevant and academically necessary.
Confidentiality
All manuscripts submitted to JSI are considered confidential documents.
Reviewers must not:
- share manuscripts with unauthorised individuals;
- disclose information about manuscripts or authors;
- reproduce or distribute manuscript materials;
- use unpublished data, ideas, arguments, or findings for personal or professional advantage; or
- retain confidential manuscript materials beyond what is reasonably necessary to complete the review.
Any request to consult another person regarding a manuscript must first receive permission from the editorial office.
The responsibility for maintaining confidentiality continues after completion of the review process.
Conflict of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could affect—or reasonably appear to affect—their impartiality.
A reviewer should decline a review invitation when a significant personal, professional, financial, institutional, supervisory, competitive, collaborative, or other relationship may compromise independent assessment.
Potential conflicts may include recent research collaboration with an author, employment at the same institution, direct academic competition, financial interests related to the research, supervisory relationships, close personal relationships, or other circumstances that may affect impartial judgement.
When uncertain whether a conflict exists, reviewers should inform the editor rather than making the determination independently.
Editors are responsible for determining whether the disclosed relationship prevents the reviewer from participating.
Use of Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review
Submitted manuscripts and reviewer reports are confidential scholarly materials.
Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, supplementary files, unpublished data, reviewer reports, or other confidential materials to generative artificial intelligence systems.
Reviewers must not use generative AI tools to:
- evaluate the scholarly quality of a submitted manuscript;
- generate substantive peer-review reports;
- make recommendations regarding acceptance or rejection; or
- replace the reviewer's own expert judgement.
The reviewer remains personally accountable for the accuracy, integrity, confidentiality, and scholarly quality of the review.
Any suspected unauthorised use of generative AI in the peer-review process may be investigated by the editorial team in accordance with JSI's publication ethics and AI policies.
Suspected Research Misconduct
If reviewers identify possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication, falsification, image manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, unethical research practices, authorship concerns, citation manipulation, or other forms of potential misconduct, they should confidentially notify the editor.
Reviewers should not directly contact the authors regarding suspected misconduct.
The editorial team will evaluate such concerns in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics Policy and applicable principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Editorial Independence
Peer review supports editorial decision-making but does not transfer editorial responsibility to reviewers.
Editors retain responsibility for:
- ensuring appropriate reviewer selection;
- considering competing reviewer opinions;
- protecting confidentiality;
- managing conflicts of interest;
- investigating ethical concerns; and
- making fair and independent publication decisions.
Commercial considerations, publication fees, institutional relationships, or other non-academic interests must not influence the outcome of peer review.
Peer Review Integrity
JSI is committed to maintaining a fair, transparent, rigorous, and independent peer-review process.
Manipulation of the peer-review process—including fabricated reviewer identities, false contact information, reviewer impersonation, coercive citation requests, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or inappropriate attempts to influence editorial decisions—is considered a serious violation of publication ethics.
Where manipulation is suspected or confirmed, JSI may reject the manuscript, withdraw an editorial decision, correct or retract a publication where appropriate, suspend individuals from participation in the journal, or take other action consistent with recognised publication-ethics practices.