Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

1. Purpose and Scope

Journal of Societal Innovation (JSI) recognises that artificial intelligence (AI), including generative artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies, is increasingly used in scholarly research, writing, data analysis, translation, and publishing.

JSI supports the responsible and transparent use of AI where such use enhances scholarly work without compromising originality, accuracy, confidentiality, intellectual property, research ethics, or human accountability.

This policy applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and all individuals involved in the publication process.

Human authors, reviewers, and editors remain fully responsible for all scholarly and editorial decisions.

2. Definition of Generative AI

For the purposes of this policy, generative AI refers to computational systems capable of generating or substantially modifying content, including text, images, audio, video, computer code, datasets, summaries, translations, or other forms of scholarly material.

Traditional tools used solely for spell checking, grammar checking, reference formatting, or basic technical editing are generally not considered substantive generative AI use unless they generate or materially alter scholarly content.

AI Use by Authors

3. Human Accountability

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and reliability of all material submitted to JSI, regardless of whether AI-assisted technologies have been used.

The use of AI does not reduce or transfer authors' responsibility for:

  • factual accuracy;
  • appropriate citation and attribution;
  • originality;
  • interpretation of findings;
  • methodological validity;
  • ethical compliance;
  • protection of confidential information; and
  • the final content of the manuscript.

Authors must carefully review and verify all AI-generated or AI-assisted content before submission.

4. AI Cannot Be an Author

Artificial intelligence systems, language models, chatbots, or other automated technologies cannot be listed as authors or co-authors.

Authorship requires the ability to take responsibility for the work, approve the final manuscript, respond to questions concerning research integrity, disclose competing interests, enter into publishing agreements, and remain accountable for the accuracy and integrity of the published work.

These responsibilities cannot be assigned to an AI system.

5. Permitted Uses of AI

Authors may use AI-assisted technologies responsibly for supportive activities such as:

  • improving grammar and language clarity;
  • supporting translation;
  • organising ideas;
  • assisting with manuscript structure;
  • assisting with coding or programming;
  • supporting data processing where methodologically appropriate;
  • assisting with literature organisation; and
  • other non-deceptive scholarly support activities.

AI-generated output must not be treated as authoritative evidence.

Authors must independently verify all facts, references, citations, calculations, interpretations, and claims generated or suggested by AI.

6. AI Uses Requiring Disclosure

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI when it has made a substantive contribution to the research or manuscript.

Disclosure is required when AI has been used for activities including:

  • generating or substantially rewriting text;
  • developing analytical code;
  • assisting with qualitative or quantitative analysis;
  • classifying or processing research data;
  • generating research materials;
  • producing or substantially modifying figures or visual materials;
  • translating substantial sections of a manuscript;
  • developing research instruments;
  • supporting systematic evidence synthesis; or
  • other activities that materially influence scholarly content.

Disclosure of responsible AI use does not automatically affect the editorial evaluation of a manuscript.

7. Generative AI Use Disclosure Statement

Where substantive AI assistance has been used, authors must include a Generative AI Use Disclosure in the manuscript.

The statement should identify:

  • the AI tool used;
  • how the tool was used;
  • the stage of research or manuscript preparation in which it was used; and
  • confirmation that the authors reviewed and take responsibility for the resulting content.

Suggested disclosure:

Generative AI Use Disclosure: During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [name and version of AI tool] for [specific purpose]. All AI-assisted content was reviewed, verified, and edited by the authors. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and final content of the manuscript.

Where no substantive generative AI was used, authors may state:

Generative AI Use Disclosure: The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence tools were used to generate substantive scholarly content in this manuscript.

Basic spelling or grammar correction that does not generate substantive content does not normally require disclosure.

8. Prohibited Uses of AI by Authors

Authors must not use AI to:

  • fabricate or falsify research data;
  • generate fictitious participants, observations, or findings;
  • invent references or sources;
  • create unsupported quotations;
  • manufacture research results;
  • manipulate results in a misleading manner;
  • conceal plagiarism;
  • misrepresent AI-generated content as independently produced empirical evidence;
  • replace essential human scholarly judgement; or
  • conceal substantive AI use where disclosure is required.

Submitting fabricated or unverified AI-generated references constitutes a breach of scholarly responsibility.

9. AI and References

AI systems should not be treated as authoritative scholarly sources for factual, theoretical, or empirical claims where an original scholarly source is available.

Authors must verify every reference suggested by an AI system against the original publication.

References that cannot be verified must not be included in the manuscript.

Fabricated, inaccurate, or misleading references may result in manuscript rejection or further investigation.

10. AI in Research Methods and Data Analysis

Where AI or machine-learning tools form part of the research methodology, their use must be transparently described in the Methods section.

Where relevant, authors should report:

  • the name of the tool or model;
  • version;
  • developer or provider;
  • date of access;
  • purpose of use;
  • input data;
  • relevant parameters or prompts;
  • validation procedures; and
  • the nature of human oversight.

The level of reporting should be proportionate to the role AI played in the research.

11. AI-Generated Images and Visual Materials

AI-generated or AI-modified images must not be used to fabricate, falsify, or misleadingly alter research evidence.

Generative AI must not be used to modify photographs, figures, charts, or other research evidence in a way that changes the underlying meaning of the data.

Where AI-generated visual materials are integral to the research itself, authors must clearly disclose the tool, purpose, generation method, and procedures used to evaluate the output.

Authors remain responsible for copyright, licensing, privacy, and ethical considerations associated with AI-generated materials.

12. Confidentiality, Privacy, and Research Data

Authors must exercise caution when entering research data into third-party AI systems.

Confidential, proprietary, sensitive, identifiable, or restricted information must not be uploaded to AI services unless:

  • such use is legally and ethically permitted;
  • appropriate participant consent or institutional approval exists where required;
  • applicable data-protection requirements are satisfied; and
  • adequate privacy and confidentiality protections are in place.

Authors remain responsible for protecting research participants, confidential information, and research data.

AI Use by Reviewers

13. Confidentiality of Submitted Manuscripts

All manuscripts submitted to JSI are confidential documents.

Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, supplementary files, unpublished data, images, reviewer forms, or other confidential submission materials to publicly accessible generative AI systems.

This requirement protects:

  • author confidentiality;
  • intellectual property;
  • unpublished research;
  • research participant privacy; and
  • confidential or restricted data.

14. AI Must Not Replace Peer Review

Reviewers must personally conduct the intellectual and scholarly assessment of manuscripts.

Generative AI must not be used to:

  • determine the scholarly quality of a manuscript;
  • assess originality on behalf of the reviewer;
  • conduct substantive methodological evaluation;
  • generate the intellectual content of a peer-review report;
  • recommend acceptance or rejection; or
  • replace the reviewer's independent scholarly judgement.

Reviewers remain personally responsible and accountable for every comment and recommendation submitted to JSI.

AI Use by Editors

15. Editorial Confidentiality

Editors must treat manuscripts, reviewer reports, author correspondence, and all associated submission materials as confidential.

Editors must not upload confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, reviewer reports, or other protected materials to publicly accessible generative AI systems.

16. Human Editorial Decision-Making

Artificial intelligence must not make final editorial decisions.

Decisions concerning:

  • desk rejection;
  • reviewer selection;
  • revision;
  • acceptance;
  • rejection;
  • ethical investigations;
  • corrections; or
  • retractions

remain the responsibility of qualified human editors.

AI-assisted tools may support administrative or technical processes, but editors retain full responsibility for editorial judgement.

17. Journal-Approved Automated Tools

JSI may use appropriately managed digital or automated tools for legitimate editorial purposes such as:

  • similarity checking;
  • plagiarism detection;
  • metadata verification;
  • manuscript completeness checks;
  • reference checking;
  • language-quality screening;
  • reviewer identification assistance; and
  • other editorial-support functions.

Such use must be subject to appropriate confidentiality, data protection, transparency, and human oversight.

18. Undisclosed or Inappropriate AI Use

If the editorial team suspects undisclosed, misleading, or unethical AI use, authors may be requested to provide additional information, including:

  • an explanation of how AI was used;
  • original research data or materials;
  • earlier manuscript versions;
  • clarification of research methods;
  • verification of references;
  • relevant prompts or outputs where necessary; or
  • other supporting documentation.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the issue, inappropriate AI use may result in:

  • a request for revision;
  • manuscript rejection;
  • withdrawal of acceptance;
  • correction;
  • expression of concern; or
  • retraction after publication.

Cases involving suspected research misconduct will be handled in accordance with the JSI Publication Ethics Policy.

19. Human Responsibility and Accountability

The use of artificial intelligence does not transfer scholarly responsibility from humans to technology.

Authors remain accountable for manuscripts.

Reviewers remain accountable for peer-review reports.

Editors remain accountable for editorial decisions.

JSI considers human accountability, transparency, confidentiality, scholarly integrity, and responsible disclosure fundamental principles governing the use of artificial intelligence in scholarly publishing.

20. Policy Review and Updates

Artificial intelligence technologies and related standards are developing rapidly.

Journal of Societal Innovation (JSI) may periodically revise this policy to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research ethics, technology, data protection, and recognised standards of publication integrity.

The version published on the JSI website represents the journal's current Artificial Intelligence Policy.